As I read the article
this week I found it very hard to find this to be a type of counseling which
could be applied to a large group of people. I know that sometimes as we are
cloudy with our decision making there is sometimes a sign that shows us the way
we need to go. However, I feel like there is not always a sign there for us
when we are trying to decide what we are looking to do with our lives.
Sometimes we make the decision to go with a certain career because it is what
we feel deep down inside is the right thing to do. We make this decision based
on what we feel not because of a dream that we have. I guess the biggest
problem I had with this theory was the dream part. I do not feel that prophetic
dreams are common enough when people are trying to make a career decision.
Also, I felt like this theory took the personal aspect
out of the career development journey. It seemed to me that this theory left a
lot of the career decision making up to chance. It would happen by chance that
if you quit your job and decide to open your own business your friend would
come through with a building for you. I mean I think this could happen for some
people but not everyone. I feel like more people are actively involved in their
career journey and I think this theory just throws that aspect out and leaves
it all up to chance and signs. I guess I personally cannot see the benefit of
this theory because I do not believe in its bases for things being left up to
chance. I personally just feel a person needs to be more invested in their
career journey and this theory I feel like leaves that crucial piece out.
The case studies were very interesting, but I think those
were three very rare cases that actually take place when a person is looking
for a new career. The third case study I found the hardest to find as truly
conceivable (2002). Her dream did work for her situation but I feel like a
person could really interpret their dream to be whatever they want it to be
showing. I think that this case study is something that can only really happen
to a person once in a while. I just really did not like this article and found
this theory to be very inapplicable to a large group of clientele.
Guindon, M., &
Hanna, F. (2002). Coincidence, happenstance, serendipity, fate, or the hand of god: Case studies in synchronicity. The
Career Development Quarterly, 50, 195-208.
No comments:
Post a Comment